Curious how the We Were Liars series compares to E. Lockhart’s bestselling novel? Here’s a quick look at the biggest differences, what stayed the same, and whether it’s worth watching.

E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars was a poetic, twisty YA novel that left readers stunned. In 2025, Prime Video brought it to the screen—but does the series do justice to the book? Let’s explore what changed, what stayed the same, and whether the adaptation is worth your watch.

🔥 The Twist? Still Devastating

The series remains faithful to the emotional core of the story. The devastating twist—Cadence is the only survivor of the Liars—is preserved. However, the series adds a new, eerie layer: Cadence’s aunt sees ghosts, too, hinting at a broader supernatural element.

This change doesn’t take away from the story—it enhances the haunting atmosphere.

👥 Character Expansion That Works

One of the biggest wins for the series is how it deepens the supporting cast.

• Gat becomes more than just Cadence’s love interest. His identity, frustrations, and conflict with the Sinclairs’ privilege are fleshed out beautifully.
• Johnny and Mirren are no longer just sidekicks. They have distinct storylines involving identity, relationships, and family pressure.
• The adult characters, especially Cadence’s mother and aunts, are given front-row drama, from messy affairs to emotional manipulation.

This all gives the series a more ensemble feel, rather than staying locked inside Cadence’s mind.

🌊 Structure & Pacing: From Dreamy to Direct

The novel’s structure is poetic and nonlinear. In contrast, the series is streamlined. For instance, Cadence’s Europe trip in the book is removed entirely, keeping all the tension on the island.

The pacing is quicker, but some fans may miss the book’s quiet mystery and introspective flow.

🧠 Social Commentary:

No More Whispering book gently critiques wealth, race, and entitlement, but the series says it out loud. From calling out colonial traditions to directly confronting inherited privilege, the adaptation makes these themes central. Depending on your taste, this may feel bold and refreshing, or a bit heavy-handed.

🎬 Final Verdict: Should You Read or Watch?

If you’re wondering where to start—or whether to do both—here’s your guide:

✅ Read the book first if you love slow burns, unreliable narrators, and poetic prose.
✅ Watch the series if you want richer backstories, visual storytelling, and modern social depth.

Either way, We Were Liars is a story that will leave a mark, whether on page or screen.